Working with pyenv-win and VSCode: Notes from Real-World Testing

Working with PowerShell and VSCode

Pyenv and VSCode Integration Workflow Step 1 pyenv local 3.10.11 Step 2 python -m venv .venv Step 3 Select Interpreter in VSCode Differences Between PowerShell and VSCode PowerShell Activation command required .venv\Scripts\activate VSCode Interpreter selection is enough (Automatic activation through UI) PATH Environment Variable Priority (Important) ✓ Correct Order: 1. pyenv-win\shims 2. pyenv-win\bin 3. System Python ✗ Incorrect Order: 1. System Python 2. pyenv-win\shims 3. pyenv-win\bin Note: Incorrect order prevents pyenv from using the specified Python version
table of contents

🧹 How to Delete a Python Virtual Environment (venv)

When working with Python in PowerShell or Visual Studio Code, deleting a virtual environment is sometimes necessary—especially when you’ve switched Python versions or your environment has become unstable.

Deleting the virtual environment is simple, but there are a few important differences depending on your operating system and shell.

🗑 How to Delete a Virtual Environment

You can remove the venv folder manually or via command line. Here are the recommended methods:

Windows – File Explorer

Right-click the venv folder and select Delete.

Windows – PowerShell or CMD

Use this PowerShell command:

Remove-Item -Recurse -Force venv

Note: Do not use rmdir /s /q venv in PowerShell. That command is specific to CMD and will result in an error in PowerShell.

Mac / Linux – Terminal

Use the following command:

rm -rf venv

This will forcefully and recursively delete the folder.

📌 When Should You Delete a Virtual Environment?

There are a few key situations where deleting and recreating your environment is recommended:

  • Your environment is broken or behaving unexpectedly.
  • You want to start fresh with clean package installations.
  • You’ve switched Python versions using pyenv, and the current environment no longer reflects the correct version.

This last point is especially important. Once a virtual environment is created, it is tied to the specific Python version that was active at the time. Even if you change the global version with pyenv, the existing virtual environment will not update. That’s why it’s often necessary to delete the old venv and create a new one.

🔧 Understanding Python Version Lock-in with pyenv and venv

When using pyenv to manage Python versions on Windows, especially with pyenv-win, it’s important to understand how Python versions interact with virtual environments.

🔒 Virtual Environments Lock in the Python Version

Once you create a virtual environment with python -m venv venv, it becomes permanently tied to the active Python version at that time.

Even if you change the version with pyenv global or pyenv local, the existing venv will not reflect that change. You must delete and recreate the virtual environment to apply a new Python version.

✅ Best Practices for Managing pyenv and venv

To ensure your virtual environment uses the correct Python version, follow these steps:

Step 1: Deactivate any active environment

If you’re already in an active virtual environment, deactivate it first:

deactivate

Step 2: Check the current global Python version

Use this command to verify the Python version currently in effect:

python -V

Example output:

Python 3.10.11

This should match the version you selected with pyenv.

Step 3: Create a new virtual environment

Now that you’re using the correct version, delete the old environment and create a new one:

python -m venv venv

This ensures that the virtual environment is built on top of the intended Python version.

Step 4: Reactivate your shell or terminal

Sometimes, changes made by pyenv aren’t applied immediately. Restart PowerShell, CMD, or your VSCode terminal to make sure the environment is refreshed.

⚙️ Why CMD and PowerShell Commands Differ

While both Command Prompt (CMD) and PowerShell are native shells in Windows, they are fundamentally different in their design and purpose. Understanding these differences is essential when working with Python, virtual environments, or tools like pyenv.

🧠 PowerShell Was Designed for System Administration

PowerShell was built with system administrators in mind. Unlike CMD, which processes only plain text, PowerShell is object-oriented and processes structured data (objects). This makes it far more powerful and versatile for automation and scripting tasks.

📚 CMD Compatibility Through Aliases

To reduce the learning curve, Microsoft added aliases to PowerShell so users could still type familiar CMD commands such as dir, cd, or del. These aliases internally map to native PowerShell commands:

CMD CommandWorks in PowerShell?PowerShell Equivalent
dir✅ YesGet-ChildItem
cd✅ YesSet-Location
del✅ Yes (with caveats)Remove-Item

⚠️ However, even though these aliases look the same, they don’t always behave exactly the same—especially when dealing with directories or non-standard file types.

🔒 Why rmdir /s Doesn’t Work in PowerShell

CMD commands like rmdir /s /q venv may result in errors when executed in PowerShell. That’s because PowerShell expects different syntax and treats parameters differently.

Instead, use:

Remove-Item -Recurse -Force venv

This is the correct PowerShell equivalent and works consistently.

🔄 Evolution for Security and Cross-Platform Use

As Windows continues to evolve, so does PowerShell. It has now become cross-platform and is available on macOS and Linux. This shift encourages more standardized, POSIX-compliant behavior, moving further away from traditional CMD conventions.

Differences and Evolution between CMD and PowerShell Command Prompt (CMD) • Text (string) based processing • Traditional shell since Windows 95 PowerShell • Object-based processing • Powerful scripting language features Evolution Alias Mechanism (for Compatibility) dir Alias Conversion Get-ChildItem cd Alias Conversion Set-Location “CMD commands work in PowerShell thanks to these aliases” Command Comparison Table Operation CMD PowerShell List Directory Contents dir Get-ChildItem (dir) Delete Directory rmdir /s Remove-Item -Recurse Delete File del filename Remove-Item filename ⚠️ Even when using aliases in PowerShell, internal behavior may differ, so use with caution

✅ In Summary

  • CMD is legacy, designed for simplicity and quick command execution.
  • PowerShell is future-focused, built for automation, scripting, and cross-platform compatibility.
  • CMD-style commands may work in PowerShell, but they are often implemented as aliases, and subtle differences can cause unexpected results.
  • Use native PowerShell commands for reliability and clarity, especially when automating tasks.

📌 Setting the Correct PATH Order for pyenv-win

When using pyenv-win to manage multiple Python versions on Windows, the order of directories listed in your system’s PATH environment variable becomes critically important.

If the PATH is not set correctly, your system may continue using the wrong version of Python—even if you’ve configured pyenv properly.

⚙️ How pyenv-win Works

pyenv-win installs Python versions into a hidden folder inside your user directory and uses shims to control which version is executed when you run the python command.

A shim is a small script (such as python.bat) located in the shims directory that acts as a proxy—it redirects to the actual Python version selected via pyenv.

🔑 Why PATH Order Matters

Windows searches through the PATH directories from top to bottom. The first matching executable it finds is the one that gets executed.

To ensure that the correct version of Python is used, the following pyenv directories must be placed at the top of your user PATH:

%USERPROFILE%\.pyenv\pyenv-win\shims  
%USERPROFILE%\.pyenv\pyenv-win\bin

If any other Python installation (e.g., from the Microsoft Store or the official Python installer) appears above these lines in your PATH, it will override the pyenv version—even if you’ve configured pyenv correctly.

🔍 How to Check and Adjust Your PATH

  1. Open the System Environment Variables dialog:
    • Press Windows + S, search for “Environment Variables”, and open Edit the system environment variables.
  2. In the User variables section, find and select PATH, then click Edit.
  3. Ensure the following two paths are listed before any other Python-related paths: %USERPROFILE%\.pyenv\pyenv-win\shims
    %USERPROFILE%\.pyenv\pyenv-win\bin
  4. Move them to the top of the list using the arrow buttons.
  5. Click OK to save changes.

🔄 Restart Your Shell After Changing PATH

After updating the PATH, be sure to restart PowerShell, CMD, or your terminal in VSCode so that the new environment settings are properly loaded.

You can verify the change using:

python -V

or

pyenv which python

These commands should now reflect the Python version managed by pyenv.

🧭 Comparing pyenv (Linux) and pyenv-win (Windows)

While both pyenv (for Linux/macOS) and pyenv-win (for Windows) share the same name and basic purpose—managing multiple Python versions—their internal implementations are very different.

Understanding these differences is essential when working across platforms or debugging environment-related issues.

🐧 pyenv for Linux (Original)

  • Designed for Unix-based systems like Linux and macOS
  • Operates in Bash or Zsh shells
  • Implements subcommands like pyenv install, pyenv which as Bash functions
  • Fully integrated into the Unix shell environment
  • Highly customizable and scriptable

🪟 pyenv-win for Windows

  • Designed specifically for Windows environments
  • Operates in PowerShell and CMD
  • Implements functionality using batch files and Python scripts
  • Independent implementation from the Linux version
  • Does not provide Linux command-line tools like ls, grep, or cat

❗Important Notes

  • The command structure of pyenv-win resembles that of Linux pyenv, but the internals are entirely different.
  • Commands like pyenv which, pyenv global are reimplemented in Python or batch scripts.
  • Standard Linux commands are not available unless you are using tools like WSL or Git Bash.

🧰 Want Linux-like commands on Windows?

MethodDescription
WSLFull Linux environment. All commands work natively.
Git BashLightweight shell with limited Linux command support.
PowerShell AliasesCommands like ls exist, but behave differently internally.

📊 See the following diagram for a visual comparison of how these systems differ:

Comparison between pyenv (Linux) and pyenv-win (Windows) pyenv for Linux (Original) • Runs in Bash/Zsh • Subcommands like pyenv which or pyenv install are implemented as Bash functions • Designed for Linux environments pyenv-win for Windows • Works with PowerShell/CMD • Implemented with custom Python scripts and batch files • Independent implementation • Linux commands are not available Important Points • pyenv command structure just looks like Linux; you can’t use Linux commands (ls, cd, grep, etc.) • Commands like pyenv which and pyenv global are provided by pyenv itself Ways to Use Linux Commands on Windows Method Description WSL Real Linux environment. All Linux commands available! Git Bash Basic Linux commands like ls, grep, cat are available PowerShell Aliases Some commands like ls work, but are different internally

🖥 How VSCode Handles Python Virtual Environments

Visual Studio Code (VSCode) offers powerful support for Python development, especially when working with virtual environments. However, the way VSCode interacts with these environments is different from how PowerShell or CMD operates.

Understanding these differences will help you avoid common mistakes and configure your workspace more effectively.

🔍 How VSCode Detects Python Environments

When you open a Python project in VSCode, the editor automatically searches for virtual environments in your workspace. It scans for known folder names like:

  • .venv
  • env
  • venv

If it finds a matching folder, it will display the associated Python interpreter in the bottom-left corner of the VSCode window.

This allows for seamless environment switching without requiring you to run activation commands manually.

💡 Tip: Naming your virtual environment folder .venv is the most compatible choice for VSCode.

🔄 Selecting a Python Interpreter in VSCode

You can manually select the Python interpreter by following these steps:

  1. Press Ctrl + Shift + P to open the Command Palette.
  2. Type "Python: Select Interpreter" and press Enter.
  3. Choose the interpreter from your .venv folder or a pyenv-managed version.

Once selected, this interpreter will be used for running, linting, and debugging Python code in that project.

📁 VSCode vs PowerShell / CMD Behavior

The key difference is how environments are activated:

EnvironmentHow Activation Works
VSCodeInterpreter selection automatically configures the environment. No need to run activation commands manually.
PowerShell / CMDYou must explicitly activate the environment using: .\venv\Scripts\activate (PowerShell) or .\venv\Scripts\activate.bat (CMD).

✅ Recommended Virtual Environment Setup for VSCode

To make VSCode integration as smooth as possible, follow this convention:

python -m venv .venv

This creates a .venv folder in the project root, which VSCode will automatically detect and prioritize.

If you’re using pyenv, make sure the desired Python version is active before running the venv command.

📌 What Happens Under the Hood?

Even though VSCode shows your selected Python version and environment visually, it doesn’t “activate” the virtual environment in the same way PowerShell or CMD does. Instead, it sets internal configuration paths and environment variables.

That’s why sometimes:

  • You don’t see (.venv) in the terminal prompt.
  • But the environment is still working as intended.

You can verify it by running:

(Get-Command python).Source

If the path points to something like .\.venv\Scripts\python.exe, you are using the virtual environment properly.

Python Virtual Environments in VSCode: .venv Best Practices python -m venv .venv Why Use .venv? 1. VSCode Automatically Recognizes This Special Name Virtual environment names VSCode auto-detects: ✓ .venv (highest priority) venv env 2. Starting with Dot (.) = Hidden Directory Linux/macOS: Treated as hidden file Windows: Hidden in some VSCode UIs 3. Consistent Path References “python.defaultInterpreterPath”: “${workspaceFolder}/.venv/Scripts/python.exe”

📄 Understanding the Role of .python-version with pyenv and VSCode

If you’re using pyenv or pyenv-win to manage multiple Python versions, you’ve likely come across a file named .python-version. This small, often overlooked file plays a crucial role in how your Python version is selected—especially within terminal sessions and certain editors like VSCode.

📌 What Is .python-version?

.python-version is a simple configuration file used by pyenv to specify which Python version should be used within a given directory.

It contains a single line of text—for example:

3.10.11

When this file exists in a folder, pyenv will automatically switch to the specified version whenever you enter that directory in the terminal.

This mechanism is known as directory-based version switching.

🔧 How to Create the File

To create a .python-version file, navigate to your project folder and run:

pyenv local 3.10.11

This command sets the Python version to 3.10.11 for that specific directory, and creates the .python-version file in the background.

💡 You can also edit this file manually—but using pyenv local is safer and ensures consistency.

🧠 How Does VSCode Use This File?

VSCode does not directly read the .python-version file. However, when the integrated terminal opens (such as PowerShell or CMD), pyenv detects the file and switches the version behind the scenes.

As a result:

  • If you create a virtual environment after switching with .python-version, it will use the correct Python version.
  • If you’re using a terminal extension or running scripts inside VSCode, the version defined in .python-version will apply automatically.

⚠️ If this file is missing, pyenv falls back to the global version, which may lead to inconsistencies.

✅ Why Is This Important?

Without .python-version, pyenv has no way of knowing which Python version to use for your project. This can cause:

  • Confusion when switching between multiple projects.
  • Mismatched Python versions in the terminal and VSCode.
  • Problems when reproducing environments across different systems or team members.

By explicitly declaring the version in .python-version, you gain:

  • Clarity: Everyone working on the project knows which version to use.
  • Consistency: VSCode terminals and automation scripts behave predictably.
  • Portability: Your project is easier to share or deploy.

📁 Should You Commit .python-version to Git?

In most cases, yes.
If your project depends on a specific Python version, including this file in version control helps teammates and CI pipelines use the same interpreter.

However, if team members use slightly different versions, it may be better to list the version requirement in your documentation or README.md instead.

🧭 Why where python May Not Work with pyenv on Windows

Why the ‘where’ Command Doesn’t Work with pyenv-win Directory Structure C:\Users\username\.pyenv\ pyenv-win\bin\ pyenv-win\shims\ python.bat ← not .exe versions\3.12.0\ python.exe ← actual executable Command Behavior Differences where python Nothing displayed pyenv which python Correct path is displayed Internal Operation during Command Execution When typing “python” in PowerShell python.bat executes Batch file processing pyenv-managed python.exe runs When typing “where python” in PowerShell where.exe executes Searches only for .exe files in PATH (.bat files are ignored)

When using pyenv-win to manage Python versions on Windows, you might run into a frustrating issue: the command where python does not return any result—or worse, it returns an outdated or incorrect path.

But don’t worry. This behavior is expected, and here’s why it happens.

🧪 The Root of the Issue: Batch Files and the shims System

Unlike Unix-based systems where pyenv uses executable shims (python, pip, etc.), the Windows version uses batch files such as python.bat.

These batch files live in the shims directory, typically:

C:\Users\<username>\.pyenv\pyenv-win\shims\

When you run the python command, you’re actually running a batch file like:

python.bat → call pyenv exec python → path to selected python.exe

This redirection happens invisibly, but it’s important for understanding what follows.

❌ Why where python May Fail in PowerShell

The where command on Windows is designed to locate executable files (.exe, .com, .bat, etc.) by searching directories listed in the PATH environment variable.

However, in PowerShell, there are some unique quirks:

  1. where may refer to PowerShell’s Where-Object cmdlet instead of where.exe.
  2. Even when calling where.exe, it sometimes ignores .bat files or prioritizes .exe files from other locations.
  3. Microsoft Store’s alias python.exe in C:\WindowsApps\ can override expected results.

✅ Recommended Alternatives for PowerShell

Instead of where python, use these more reliable commands:

Option 1: Use pyenv directly

pyenv which python

This shows the actual full path to the Python version selected by pyenv.

Option 2: Use PowerShell’s Get-Command

(Get-Command python).Source

This tells you exactly which script or executable will run when you type python.

Example output:

C:\Users\yourname\.pyenv\pyenv-win\shims\python.bat

This means you’re correctly using the version managed by pyenv-win.

🧠 What This All Means

Even if where python doesn’t return what you expect, it does not mean your setup is broken.

  • Your terminal is still using the correct version through pyenv’s shim system.
  • VSCode and virtual environments will continue to work as long as pyenv is configured properly.
  • The discrepancy is only in how PowerShell resolves python for display purposes.

🧭 Why where python Returns Nothing on a Windows PC Without pyenv

Why ‘where python’ Doesn’t Work in PowerShell (Also occurs in standard Python environments without pyenv) Environment Variable Status (Normal) PATH=C:\Program Files\Python311\;C:\Program Files\Python311\Scripts\;… ✓ Correctly configured Command Behavior Differences with the Same PATH Setting Command Prompt (CMD) C:\> where python C:\Program Files\Python311\python.exe PowerShell PS C:\> where python Problems with the ‘where’ Command in PowerShell Two Meanings of ‘where’ 1. Alias for Where-Object (PowerShell) 2. Windows standard ‘where.exe’ external command Reasons for Unstable Behavior • Ambiguity in command interpretation • where.exe prioritizes .exe files and ignores .bat Recommended Command (Always Works) (Get-Command python).Source

You might assume that if pyenv isn’t installed, running where python should at least show the system-installed Python path. But on many Windows setups, especially fresh ones, it simply returns nothing.

This behavior often surprises developers—but it’s entirely explainable.

❓ What Could Cause This?

Here are some common scenarios where where python fails even without pyenv:

🔸 A. Python Is Not Installed at All

The most obvious reason: Python hasn’t been installed yet.

  • There’s no python.exe on your system.
  • So there’s nothing for where to find.

Solution: Download and install Python from the official python.org site or via the Microsoft Store.

🔸 B. Only a Microsoft Store Alias Exists

Windows 10 and 11 sometimes include a virtual placeholder for Python at:

C:\WindowsApps\python.exe

But this is not a real Python interpreter. It’s just a shortcut that opens the Microsoft Store.

  • where python may still return nothing because the file is hidden or lacks execution permissions.
  • Even if it’s shown, trying to run python might open the Store instead of a terminal session.

Solution: Avoid using the Microsoft Store version and install Python directly from python.org for better compatibility.

🔸 C. Python Is Installed, but Not in PATH

Sometimes Python is installed properly, but the installer option “Add Python to PATH” was left unchecked.

  • This means Python exists, but Windows has no way to locate it.
  • where python will return nothing because it’s not in any of the directories listed in PATH.

Solution: Manually add the Python installation directory (e.g., C:\Users\YourName\AppData\Local\Programs\Python\Python311\) to your system PATH.

🧪 How to Check if Python Is Actually Installed

Try running this in PowerShell:

[System.Diagnostics.Process]::Start("python").Path

If Python is installed, this will return the full path to python.exe. If not, it will throw an error.

✅ In Summary

Even without pyenv, there are several reasons why where python might return nothing:

ScenarioCauseSolution
Python isn’t installedNo interpreter existsInstall Python from python.org
Microsoft Store aliasOnly a virtual shortcutAvoid using Store versions
Python not in PATHInstaller option was uncheckedManually add to PATH

Understanding these behaviors helps avoid misdiagnosing issues when working with Python on Windows—especially in clean or beginner environments.

⚙ Using .vscode/settings.json to Automate Virtual Environment Setup in VSCode

If you’re working with Python in Visual Studio Code, configuring .vscode/settings.json in your project folder is one of the most effective ways to ensure consistent environment behavior—especially when sharing projects across teams or devices.

This configuration file helps automate interpreter selection, activate your virtual environment automatically, and enforce consistent coding standards.

📁 Where to Place It

Create a .vscode folder in the root of your project (if it doesn’t already exist), and inside it, create or edit the settings.json file:

your-project/
├── .vscode/
│   └── settings.json
├── .venv/
├── main.py
└── requirements.txt

✨ Recommended Settings

Here’s an example of a robust settings.json configuration for Python projects:

{
  "python.defaultInterpreterPath": "${workspaceFolder}/.venv/Scripts/python.exe",
  "python.terminal.activateEnvironment": true,
  "python.linting.enabled": true,
  "python.formatting.provider": "black",
  "editor.formatOnSave": true
}

🧠 What Each Setting Does

SettingDescription
python.defaultInterpreterPathPoints to the virtual environment interpreter. Ensures VSCode uses the correct Python version.
python.terminal.activateEnvironmentAutomatically activates the environment when a new terminal opens.
python.linting.enabledTurns on linting to catch syntax and logic errors.
python.formatting.providerSets your code formatter to Black, a popular opinionated formatter.
editor.formatOnSaveAutomatically formats your code every time you save the file.

💡 Tip: On macOS or Linux, change the interpreter path to ./.venv/bin/python instead of Scripts/python.exe.

🚀 Benefits of This Approach

  • ✅ You never have to manually activate your environment.
  • ✅ VSCode instantly uses the right Python version for that project.
  • ✅ Teams working on the same repo get identical behavior.
  • ✅ Linting and formatting are consistent, reducing code style conflicts.

👥 Great for Team Collaboration

This method is especially helpful in team projects. By committing .vscode/settings.json to your Git repository, every team member who opens the project in VSCode will benefit from the same environment and coding standards—without any manual setup.

🛠 Troubleshooting: Virtual Environment Not Activated or Interpreter Not Detected in VSCode

Even with all the correct tools and settings in place, it’s not uncommon to encounter issues where:

  • The virtual environment doesn’t activate in the terminal.
  • VSCode doesn’t recognize the Python interpreter.
  • The (.venv) prefix is missing from the terminal prompt.

Here are the most common causes—and how to resolve them.

Python Environment Troubleshooting Problem: Python Interpreter Not Found Select Interpreter from Command Palette Check PATH Order pyenv-win shims first Completely Restart VSCode Problem: Virtual Environment Cannot Be Activated Change PowerShell Execution Policy Set-ExecutionPolicy RemoteSigned -Scope CurrentUser Use Different Terminal in VSCode e.g., Command Prompt instead of PowerShell Problem: Package Installation Errors Update pip to Latest python -m pip install –upgrade pip Recreate Virtual Env Remove old env and recreate Check Wheel Packages Check for binary dependencies Recommended Workflow 1. Set Python version with pyenv → 2. Create virtual env → 3. Select in VSCode → 4. Start developing

❌ Problem 1: The Terminal Doesn’t Show (.venv) Prompt

You’ve created a virtual environment and selected the interpreter in VSCode, but the terminal doesn’t show the environment as active.

✅ Solution

  1. Check settings.json
    Ensure you have the following line:
"python.terminal.activateEnvironment": true
  1. Restart the Terminal
    After changing settings, always restart the terminal in VSCode. You can do this by clicking the trash icon and opening a new terminal.
  2. Activate Manually (if needed)
    If auto-activation fails, run this command manually (for PowerShell):
.\.venv\Scripts\Activate.ps1

Or for CMD:

.\.venv\Scripts\activate.bat

❌ Problem 2: Python Interpreter Is Missing or Wrong in VSCode

VSCode may not list your virtual environment’s interpreter, or it may default to the wrong Python version.

✅ Solution

  1. Manually Select Interpreter
    Press Ctrl + Shift + P, type "Python: Select Interpreter" and choose the path to your .venv interpreter.
  2. Use .python-version with pyenv
    If you’re using pyenv, make sure the version is defined in a .python-version file. Then restart your terminal in VSCode.
  3. Verify the Interpreter Path
    In the terminal, run:
(Get-Command python).Source

It should return something like:

C:\YourProject\.venv\Scripts\python.exe

If it doesn’t, VSCode is not using the expected interpreter.

❌ Problem 3: Python Scripts Won’t Run Properly

You try to run a Python script, but get errors like ModuleNotFoundError, even though the module is installed.

✅ Solution

  1. Check the Environment Used to Run the Script
    VSCode might be running the file using a different interpreter than expected. Make sure the correct one is selected (bottom-left corner of the editor).
  2. Inspect Your Terminal Prompt
    If the prompt doesn’t start with (.venv), your virtual environment may not be active.
  3. Run pip in the Same Environment
    To confirm you’ve installed packages into the right environment, try:
pip show <package-name>

If it returns nothing, you may have installed it globally or in another environment.

🧪 New Insight: .python-version Might Not Be Required After All?

Through recent testing, we discovered something unexpected:

When using VSCode + pyenv-win, it turns out that Python environments can still function properly even without a .python-version file.

Yes—really.

While documentation often emphasizes its importance, in practice, certain combinations of tools and settings allow things to “just work” even if the file is missing.

✅ Conditions where .python-version is not required:

  • You’re using a recent version of pyenv-win (v3.12.0 or later).
    Shim behavior has become more robust and predictable.
  • The VSCode Python extension is up to date.
    Interpreter auto-detection has improved significantly in recent versions.
  • Your PATH is properly configured.
    The pyenv-win\shims directory is placed at the top of your user PATH variable.

If these three conditions are met, VSCode may automatically detect the correct Python version associated with your pyenv setup—without needing a .python-version file.

💡 Previously (e.g., with pyenv 3.11.x), we observed that environment detection failed unless .python-version existed, and VSCode often required a full restart after changing versions.
With the latest updates, this behavior seems to have improved.

✅ Should You Still Use .python-version?

Yes—as a best practice, especially when working in teams or automating deployments.
It makes your environment deterministic and less dependent on external factors like PATH or editor behavior.

But it’s good to know that it may not be strictly required in all situations anymore.

🔍 Final Checklist: Is Everything Working?

CheckExpected Result
(.venv) appears in terminal prompt
python -V shows expected version
Get-Command python points to .venv
Packages installed with pip are found
Interpreter is selected in VSCode UI

If all of these are true, your environment is correctly set up!

💡 Use Cases Where .python-version Isn’t Necessary

While .python-version is a best practice in many workflows, there are plenty of real-world scenarios where it’s simply not needed:

  • Solo development on a fixed environment
    If you’re the only one working on the code, and you’re not switching Python versions often, you can skip it.
  • Quick tests or experiments
    When you just want to spin up a .venv to test something, you don’t always need full version pinning.
  • You’ve already selected the interpreter in VSCode
    If the interpreter is set and shows in the bottom-left corner, and your terminal opens with (.venv) active, then you’re good to go.

✅ What counts as “success”?

To confirm that your virtual environment is correctly set up and active:

  1. You see .venv selected in VSCode, like:
    Python 3.12.0 64-bit ('.venv': venv)
  2. Your terminal prompt starts with (.venv), such as:
    (.venv) PS C:\YourProject>
  3. The Python executable is actually the one inside .venv
    Run:
    (Get-Command python).Source
    and check that the result points to:
    .\.venv\Scripts\python.exe

🎯 If all three of these are true—your virtual environment is working. You don’t need .python-version in this case.

🎓 Real-World Lessons & Closing Thoughts

If you’ve made it this far, congratulations—you’re already ahead of many developers who still struggle with Python environment inconsistencies on Windows.

Here are a few final thoughts based on real-world experience that don’t always show up in documentation, but make all the difference:

  • A virtual environment remembers the Python version it was created with.
    If something feels off, delete it and recreate it. That alone solves half of the problems.
  • Shims are powerful but fragile.
    They do their job quietly—until something else hijacks your PATH. When in doubt, run pyenv doctor.
  • VSCode doesn’t always show (.venv)—and that’s okay.
    What matters is which Python is running, not what your prompt looks like.
  • Don’t underestimate .python-version.
    That tiny file makes your environment predictable. It’s invisible magic, especially when working across machines or teams.
  • The best setup is the one you don’t have to think about.
    If you configure things right once—.venv, settings.json, and requirements.txt—you rarely have to touch them again.

🧩 Bonus tip: If things feel weird… reboot your terminal. If they still feel weird… check your PATH. If they still feel weird… get coffee and start over.

🪪 Final Note

This guide is based on trial, error, and a bit of stubbornness.
There’s no one-size-fits-all solution, but hopefully, this gave you a system that works—and makes sense.

If it helped, consider saving a copy for future projects, or even better: teach someone else what you learned.
There’s nothing more satisfying than seeing someone go from “Why won’t it work?” to “Oh, now I get it.”

If you like this article, please
Follow !

Please share if you like it!
table of contents